September 2019

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30          

« BC BS | Main | Terminators »

May 22, 2009

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

winstongator

Black-Scholes is not perfect, and is one of the equations that mispriced many options leading to today's mess, and was so useful at LTCM.

ONB received $100M 6 months ago. Treasury got back $100M (preferred paid back at par), pref dividend $2.5M (5%/yr), and the $1.2M for the warrants. An annualized 7.4% return on their investment. If we get that rate of return, assuming TARP funds get completely repaid in 2 years, the feds would make $115Bln profit on the program. The warrants were a bonus, part of the cost of getting TARP funds.

"each of the 813,000 warrants had a strike price of $18.45...Based on that volatility and that rate, the Black-Scholes options valuation tool appraised one Old National warrant at $7.18. The bank paid the U.S. $1.48 for each." ONB is currently trading at $12.22. To justify the $7/share option price, ONB stock would have to more than double. Are bank stocks going to double on a whole? If that happens, what will the rest of the market do?

The worse situation is the preferred to common stock swap, as the ratio of # of shares of common to each preferred has not been negotiated the best. It is this where the $25B put into Citi, only buys us a 40% stake, while Citi's market cap is only $20B today. If we put $25B into Citi common stock today, we would buy it out, with $5B to spare!

Valuing other options: Citi got its TARP funds on 10/28, when its common was at $13, now it is at $4. BAC was at $22, now at $11. For the Citi warrants to be worth anything, Citi stock would have to over triple, and Bank of America would have to double.

Right now, Citi options at $12 are trading at 9 cents/share. ONB options at 17.50 appear to be trading between $0.75-$1.35/share.
http://www.nasdaq.com/aspxcontent/options2.aspx?symbol=ONB&selected=ONB&qm_page=65603&qm_symbol=ONB
If these analysts really thought those options were so valuable, wouldn't they be scooping them up at such reduced prices, pushing the price up?

The comments to this entry are closed.