GSO/Guilford Pols

November 2014

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30            

« Cutting their way to prosperity | Main | Carolyn LeBauer »

Mar 08, 2012

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341cc33e53ef016763924af3970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Peer editing the New York Times:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Mick

Is that the Batman emblem on his chest?

Joe Killian

An interesting, word-for-word graphic adaptation of "A Princess of Mars" by a Burroughs aficionado and fellow North Carolinian.

Not Safe for Work.

Ian McDowell

Touche, but who is my Dejah Thoris? I only know one woman who looks like a Frank Frazetta painting come to life (appropriately enough, she wrote much of the Wiki entry on the late Russ Meyer, whom she knew but is too young to have ever acted for). Sadly, Amanda is married to someone else and living in London.

Like Mick, I've noticed the way John Carter's medallion resembles the Batman emblem. However, that's not something that would have occurred to me or Frazetta back in 1971, when that symbol looked rather different. It's always been a stylized bat, and since the 60s, a stylized bat in a gold or yellow oval, but it wasn't until the 1989 Tim Burton movie that it looked like that.

Ian McDowell

And Joe, wow, that's some really obsessive stuff there. If you want to see James Killian Spratt's work in uncensored form, you have to click the link at the bottom of the Boingboing post, which takes you to www.comicsbeat.com, and then click the first link on THAT page, to get to a navigable index of all of the chapter of A Princess of Mars that Spratt has adapted so far. Of you can just copy and paste the following link. Don't worry, it's not a porn site and there's no spam, it's hosted by ERBzine, a Burroughs fansite.

http://www.erbzine.com/mag13/1301.html

Reading the Barsoom novels as a kid, I have to admit that I often wondered if John Carter's description of himself as "naked except for my harness" really meant that he was leaping around in nothing but his sword belt and gun strap, his man-parts dangling in the Martian breeze. Spratt's answer is an emphatic yes.


Ed Cone

Ian, your Dejah Thoris is akin to the robust man wearing a sash labeled "Copper Interests" in a 19th Century political cartoon -- she is a stand-in for all the beautiful and scantily-clad readers of this blog.

Billy Jones

Ed, "a stand-in for all the beautiful and scantily-clad readers of this blog."

Thanks! I didn't know you noticed.

Ian McDowell

Crikey, now I'm imagining Billy in some combination of diaphanous silks and leather. No, no, words not pictures!

Considering the importance of Ian and Betty Ballantine to the publishing industry, and the status their paperback line had throughout the 60s and 70s, I'm surprised someone at the Times would misspell their name (not that I've not more equally egregious errors). I can't imagine Michael Dirda making the same mistake over at the Post.

Ian McDowell

Speaking of Michael Dirda, there's a very nice piece by him about Burroughs and Barsoom at today's BarnesandNobleReview.com site. As usual, he writes about genre fiction with clarity and sans condescension.

A Dreamer of Mars

There's the now expected Frazetta confusion, although it's more minor here. He refers to cover illustrations for the Barsoom books having been done in the 60s by Frazetta and Roy Krenkel (Frazetta's longtime friend from his school days, and occasionally his collaborator). As I keep saying, while Frazetta and Krenkel were all over the 60s Ace editions of Burroughs' work, either singly or together, and Ace did publish some Barsoom novels before losing the rights to Ballantine in '62 or '63, I'm pretty sure that their Barsoom editions all had covers by Krenkel solo (Frazetta did Tarzan and Pellucidar and Carson of Venus for them). At least, the only Ace Barsoom covers a Google image search turns up are a couple by Krenkel.

Billy Jones

Ian, are you saying you don't find me attractive?

Ian McDowell

Not at all sir, you are a striking fellow! I just don't think the Burlesque Queen of Outer Space attire that A Princess of Mars is typically depicted as wearing is really your style.

Billy Jones

Ian, "I just don't think the Burlesque Queen of Outer Space attire that A Princess of Mars is typically depicted as wearing is really your style."

You're probably right, my butt is too big.

The comments to this entry are closed.