It may seem redundant to include an Adam Sandler movie in our Bad Review of the Day feature, but remember, it's the review, not the work reviewed, that qualifies;
Anyway:
It doesn’t get worse than "Grown Ups," Adam Sandler’s sloppy entry into this year's man-child-comedy sweepstakes. Lazy, mean-spirited, incoherent, infantile and, above all, witless...
Meanwhile, Scott Card and I finally
agree on a movie, although how he knows the 3-D version he did not see is no good is a puzzler.
His question about free will and toy loyalty struck me, too. Card calls his own framing of these issues in terms of slavery "weird," but the real problem with it is that toy owners do not even suspect that the toys are sentient beings, so there is no rationalization required when treating them like objects. Whatever drama exists around this existential question -- and I agree, there is some -- it's all among the toys, which must struggle for meaning like small, plastic Stephen Cranes.
Bonus Toy Story 3 review: "[T]he film displays the same careless sexism as its predecessors."
There's a reasonable argument that Pixar films are boy-centric, although that critique overlooks the strong women in The Incredibles (which deserves more criticism for its ubermenschen mythos than its sexism).
But [spoiler alert!] it may be worth noting that the villain of TS3 is a male -- a male bear, but still -- not to mention a rip-off of the (male) villain of TS2, with the same abandonment issues faced by Jessie in that movie.
Recent Comments