Facebook vs Scoble.
Carr adjudicates.
Blogads
blog advertising is good for you
Guilford County
- Aggregator - Greensboro101
- Allen Johnson
- Billy the Blogging Poet
- Busy Being Born
- Chosen Fast
- Dave Ribar
- Doug Clark
- Gate City
- Greening Guilford
- Greensboring
- Greensboro Politics
- Guarino
- Hoggard
- Inside Furniture
- Inside Scoop
- Joe Killian
- Joel Gillespie
- John Robinson
- Kim
- Lex Alexander
- Mathew Gross
- N&R Letters
- Patrick Eakes
- Piedmont Publius
- Plead the First
- Rambling Prose
- Sue's Place
- Triad Watch
- Vie de Malchance
- Viewfinder Blues
- Visual
GSO/Guilford Pols
Local & State News
« Tonight | Main | As seen on teevee »
Jan 03, 2008
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341cc33e53ef00e54fbea6908833
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference All your data are belong to us:
Comments
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
Verify your Comment
Previewing your Comment
This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment
As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.
Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.
Recent Comments
- Ed Cone on Esculent adventure
- Jerry Bledsoe on Esculent adventure
- Doug H on Esculent adventure
- Kim on Esculent adventure
- Ian McDowell on Esculent adventure
- Ian McDowell on Esculent adventure
- Steve Harrison on Esculent adventure
- RecycleBill on Esculent adventure
- Beelzebubba on Esculent adventure
- cheripickr on Esculent adventure
Far Away
North Carolina
- anonyMoses
- Anton Zuiker
- Blue NC
- DrFrankLives
- Exile on Jones Street
- Gerry Canavan
- Henry Copeland
- Isaac Hunter's Tavern
- IsThatLegal?
- Jack Betts
- John Hood
- Jon Lowder
- Kids Prefer Cheese
- Life in Forsyth
- NC Blogs
- NC Zoo
- Orange Politics
- Paul Jones
- Pearce & Wrenn
- RC3
- Ruby Sinreich
- Ryan Irelan
- Under the Dome
Nick opines, not adjudicates, IMO. There is no law (yet) in this area but how many PR hits can Facebook take in one 12-month period? After the "tell everyone what you buy, read and own" script nightmare, how can they claim that the data is theirs? Perhaps if Plaxo had offered money instead of an alpha trial without warning, we wouldn't be reading this.
DM is right: what Scoble did was against the rules. Not for profit? Doesn't matter. He didn't know about Data Portability when he did it (but is now an evangelist; interesting what can happen in 24 hours), so no righteous excuses for him.
However, forget scraping, forget TOS, forget intentions. Facebook cannot have it both ways and argue data ownership is one-sided. It takes a Scoble to get this issue to the front of the discussion. And all's well that temporarily ends well, eh?
Posted by: Sue | Jan 03, 2008 at 06:19 PM